Skip to content

Supply Chain Defense · How we compare

Four ways to manage supplier risk, and what each leaves with you

Third-party cyber risk is sold in very different shapes. Some tools ask suppliers about themselves. Some score suppliers from the outside. Some send consultants on site once a year. The difference that matters is not the feature list. It is how much of the work still lands on your team: deciding what is real, chasing the supplier, and checking the fix.

At a glance

The four approaches

Questionnaires and self-assessmentSecurity-ratings platformPeriodic consulting auditsFully managed service
What it tells youWhat the supplier says about itselfAn outside-in scoreA detailed picture, once a yearAn outside-in score, continuously, validated by analysts
Who checks it is trueNobody, usuallyNobody: false positives are yours to sortThe auditors, at that momentAnalysts, before it reaches you
Who contacts the supplierYour teamYour teamThe consultants, during the auditThe analysts, with follow-up (directed tier)
Zero-day responseNoneAn alert, if anyNoneAffected suppliers identified and warned within hours
CoverageAs many suppliers as you can chaseBroadA handful of suppliersCritical suppliers analyst-led, the long tail automated
Your team’s effortHighHighMedium, per auditLow: read escalations, step in when a supplier will not act
The ratings question

Why a score alone is not enough

A security rating is the same kind of data this service starts from. The difference is what happens after it.

  • The footprint is checked by people

    A vulnerable server wrongly attributed to your supplier is a common source of false positives, and a common reason suppliers stop taking ratings seriously.

  • Findings are validated before they reach you

    Out of around 30,000 findings a month across a client’s suppliers, about 150 are escalated to the client.

  • Someone takes it to the supplier

    In the directed tier the analysts contact the supplier, recommend a fix and follow up. That is the step a rating leaves with you, and it is the step that changes the remediation rate: analyst-led, 85% of critical findings were fixed within 90 days; unassisted, 37% (BlueVoyant, August 2023).

Why this one

Key capabilities of the service

  • Dedicated analysts, working both with you and with your suppliers, not just an online platform.
  • Manual curation of each supplier’s footprint, and manual checks of every critical and high finding.
  • Direct access and expert support for your suppliers, in their own portal, with no limit on the number of their users.
  • Questionnaire answers and threat intelligence evaluated together, with deviations flagged automatically.
  • Zero-day guidance in as little as 90 minutes after disclosure, for vulnerabilities detectable from outside, and in the directed tier straight to the affected suppliers.
  • Pricing by number of suppliers only, regardless of their size or IP addresses.
  • A local partner: your contract is with Spirity, your first call is answered in Hungarian or German, and your suppliers are written to in their language.
Before you sign

Seven questions to ask any provider

  1. 01

    Who validates a finding before it reaches us?

    Ask for the false-positive rate on findings delivered to clients, not on raw data.

  2. 02

    Who checks that the infrastructure attributed to a supplier is really theirs?

    Misattribution is where most false positives start.

  3. 03

    Who contacts the supplier, and who follows up?

    If the answer is “you”, count the hours.

  4. 04

    What happens on the day a major zero-day is disclosed?

    Ask for the timeline, not the feature name.

  5. 05

    Can suppliers see and answer their own findings?

    And do they pay, or count against a user limit, to do so?

  6. 06

    Are questionnaire answers checked against anything?

    An unchecked answer is a statement, not evidence.

  7. 07

    What sets the price?

    Supplier size and IP count can make the long tail expensive.

Limits

Where this stops

It is not an audit. External monitoring does not see a supplier’s internal controls. For your most critical suppliers, audits and evidence-based questionnaires still have a place, and this service makes them sharper rather than replacing them.

It is not the cheapest option. When you compare prices, count the analyst time, the supplier outreach and the follow-up alongside the licence fee: that work is what you are paying for.

Questionnaires and consulting

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

The questions we hear most often from security and IT leaders.

Something not covered here? Ask us directly

The data is similar. What a ratings platform leaves with you is deciding which findings are real, contacting the supplier and checking the fix. Here analysts curate the footprint, validate findings above your threshold, and in the directed tier follow up with the supplier on the fix.

Products change faster than web pages, and a comparison that was fair last year may not be this year. If you are comparing specific providers, ask us and we will go through it with you using their current public information.

No, it makes them checkable. Questionnaires cover internal controls monitoring cannot see; monitoring catches answers the footprint contradicts.

Where to go next

Related pages

  • Remediation

    Findings above your threshold validated by an analyst, with a recommended fix and, in the directed tier, supplier outreach.

    Learn more

  • Service tiers

    BlueVoyant-Directed, Client-Directed and High Volume Monitoring, and which fits which supplier.

    Learn more

  • Zero-day response

    Affected suppliers identified and warned within hours of a critical disclosure.

    Learn more

Ready to get started?

Partner with Spirity Enterprise to implement the right security and IT solutions for your organization.